Monday, August 11, 2008

Tenth Dimension Polls Archive 17

Click here for the archive of polls 1 to 10.
Click here for the archive of polls 11 to 15.

Poll #17 - Max Planck said: "A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."
(Poll ended June 30 08)
70 % agreed while the rest disagreed.

Another more succinct version of this quote is "science progresses by funerals".

As a person with an unusual approach to thinking about how our reality is derived, which some people embrace and some people reject as bunk, I of course take some comfort from Max Planck's idea presented in this quote. Will my dimensional hierarchy's connections to mainstream science ever be embraced by the mainstream or will this remain nothing more than an intellectual curiosity? Only time will tell. History is full of naysayers and established experts who ridiculed new ideas: there are many famous quotes that have been gathered in various places around the net. Michio Kaku, in his new book Physics of the Impossible, starts each chapter with quotes from famous historical figures and their comments on new ideas. This one, from a respected physicist just over a century ago, is typical of the kind of thinking that Max Planck is referring to:

"Radio has no future. Heavier-than-air flying machines are impossible. X-rays will prove to be a hoax." - Physicist Lord Kelvin, 1899


Next Poll Question - is it impossible to completely know a mystery that we're part of?

3 comments:

gregory said...

the mind cannot know, the self can know .. for the distinction, see advaita vedanta ... which you may not be interested in.

great blog you have, amazing. makes me glad to be alive.

Rob Bryanton said...

Thanks for the great comment, gregory! I looked up advaita vedanta and then just vedanta in wikipedia - I agree, there are some very interesting connections there to the underlying enfolded symmetry state behind our reality that I'm speaking about with this project.

Enjoy the journey,

Rob

myspace polls said...

I agree with Gregory, makes perfect sense to me. The connections are very interesting.

Tenth Dimension Vlog playlist